This pattern was great. This was my first time making clothes from an independent pattern maker and I am really impressed. I have had not too great results using Simplicity, Kwik Sew, McCalls, etc. The directions given aren't always the best way to assemble the garment, and the patterns tend to be ill fitting. But this pattern the fit was perfect. The sizing was perfect. The instructions are clear and include color photos. It goes together fairly quickly (considering it is completely lined) and the sewing is fairly simple. The pattern comes in a pdf file so you have to print it out and assemble it, so the downside is it takes a bit longer, but the upside is quick "shipping" (it took one day for her to email the pattern to me). The sweatshirt is completely lined so it is warm, and no seams are showing, so the finish is professional looking even if you don't have a serger.
I've made three of these sweatshirts so far. The first I made was actually Selena's Halloween costume. I made it with a weird poly minky type fabric for the shell and a dark green non-stretchy cotton knit inner. I added blue spikes and a tail. The second I made of some nice 100 Polartec fleece on the inside, and a cheap waffle knit print on the outside. The third I made from some 200 weight Polartec Fleece on the outside and a gray Joann's cotton knit on the inside. (I am on a mission to use significant amounts of fabric from my stash.) I used poly-resin snaps instead of buttons. The instructions give two options for the sleeve cuffs. I chose the simpler method of not adding a cuff because sewing cuffs on really tiny sleeves is hard. My only tips that were not included in the instructions are to machine baste the hood onto the outer shell, and to machine the bottom trim together before attaching to the main body. In both cases there are lots of layers and it made my life a bit easier. Also the pattern is not reversible. I initially thought it was. When I realized it wasn't I thought I could make it reversible by using the snaps, but you can't. The overlapping front makes it not work.
Selena loves the sweatshirts and only tells me how snuggly warm they are. She also brags to people and tells them that I made it for her.
If you are wondering, Selena chose to wear shorts with leg warmers that day. :)
** This recommendation is purely my own opinion. I paid for the pattern and am not receiving any compensation for this review.